Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Tenured Radicals -- Prototypical Judgment Quality

Ever wonder if the craziness and anti-patriotism of some in my profession are exaggerated? Mark Newgent informs me that "The American Educational Research Association [AERA]...members recently elected [William] Ayers the head of its curriculum studies division. That means his radical brand of education philosophy has further entrenched itself into the mainstream."

"Read on...Vatzian sighted piece:


3,000 professors sign to support William Ayers



By Stephanie Bernhard
Brown Daily Herald



Editor's Note: Stephanie Bernhard is a writer for the Brown Daily Herald, the leading news source for Brown University. This article was brought to CNN.com by UWIRE, the leading provider of student-generated content. UWIRE aims to identify and promote the brightest young content creators and deliver their work to a larger audience via professional media partners such as CNN.com. Visit UWIRE.com to learn more.


Former Weather Underground member William Ayers leaves the Criminal Courts Building in Chicago in 1980.


(UWIRE) -- More than 3,000 educators nationwide, including six Brown University professors, have signed a statement supporting William Ayers -- the man Republican presidential nominee Sen. John McCain called a "washed-up terrorist" at the third presidential debate.

In recent months, the McCain campaign has criticized Democratic presidential nominee Sen. Barack Obama for his connection to Ayers. McCain and his running mate, Gov. Sarah Palin, have accused Obama of being "friends" with Ayers and claimed Obama has hidden the extent of their relationship.

Both residents of the Chicago, Illinois, area, Ayers and Obama first met in 1995 when they served on the board of the Chicago Annenberg Challenge, a school reform initiative. They also were board members of the Woods Fund, a Chicago charity, from 2000 to 2002.

Ayers, now a distinguished professor of education and senior university scholar at the University of Illinois at Chicago, was a co-founding member of the radical activist group the Weather Underground in 1969. The group's extreme tactics to end the Vietnam War included planting bombs in the Pentagon and the United States Capitol.

In response to the McCain campaign's focus on Ayers' radical acts of the 1960s and 1970s, "Friends and supporters of Bill Ayers" are circulating a statement online to vouch for the professor he has become.

"I think he's doing a lot of positive, progressive, constructive work right now," said Brown University English professor William Keach, the first member of the university's faculty to sign the statement of support. Keach was referring to Ayers's work in the field of education.

As a professor, Ayers has written more than a dozen books on his holistic approach to learning that downplays the boundaries between teacher and student. Ayers was one of the original proponents of "free schools," where students call teachers by their first names and don't receive grades on assignments.

Don't Miss
In Depth: Election 2008
UWIRE: Voter turnout still low for youngest age bracket
UWIRE: Commentary -- Obama's past
UWIRE: Professor develops voter type model
Constance Crawford, an adjunct lecturer in theater, speech and dance, was educated in free schools and said she disagrees with the concept, favoring a more traditional approach. But she signed the statement supporting Ayers, and said his ideas "should be combated with clarity, not with personal demonization and vilification."

Keach voiced a similar opinion regarding Ayers's involvement with the Weather Underground, saying he "disagree(s) with Ayers's tactics," but he signed the statement "without any hesitation." Keach also protested the Vietnam War in the 1960s and 1970s, and said he wanted to show "solidarity" with Ayers. He said he wished Obama could have done the same when Ayers came up during the third debate.

"He's being unnecessarily cautious," Keach said.

Ayers entered the debate in the context of a question about both sides' negative campaigning. Ayers hosted a coffee event for Obama's first office run in 1995, prompting McCain to say to Obama, "You launched your political campaign in Mr. Ayers' living room."

Obama responded, saying, "Mr. Ayers is not involved in my campaign. He has never been involved in this campaign. And he will not advise me in the White House."

Keach thinks "it's disturbing that he had to take such a dismissive approach." He added Obama could have "brought up the positive things about the person (Ayers) has become."

Crawford signed the statement supporting Ayers because she thinks it is necessary to appreciate the man's accomplishments, not just what she calls the mistakes of his past.

"It's easy to paint someone with a broad brush," she said. "It's easy to vilify, but it's harder to consider."

2 comments:

Gunpowder Chronicler said...

I wonder what the opinion of these 3,000 individuals would be had the Terrorist Ayers or his wife had attempted to blow up a university building?

What would their reaction be if a "right-wing" domestic terrorist attempted to blow up a university building today?

The simple fact is that reasonable people can't move beyond his terrorist acts -- remember, his girlfriend was killed while building bombs for the enlisted dance at Ft Dix -- if he had showed the least bit of contrition or repentance.

Until then, this is just a list of 3,000 more over-educated people proving the adage "those who can, do, and those can't, teach."

Tony Resecurte ( r) said...

I wonder what the american public would be thinking if Bush had not create the mess he has created.

Who cares? It is what it is.

ShareThis